A prospective comparison of peritoneal dialysis to hemodialysis was undertaken to identify advantages and disadvantages of either treatment relative to the other. While a kidney transplant is considered the best treatment option for esrd whenever possible, dialysis will likely be necessary in the waiting period before surgery. Peritoneal dialysis vs hemodialysis peritoneal dialysis. Hemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis are associated with similar outcomes for endstage renal disease treatment in canada. It is important for you to consider all aspects of both dialysis modalities, hemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis before deciding on which one to adopt.
Difference between dialysis and hemodialysis compare the. The alternative is peritoneal dialysis, which most patients carry out themselves either. Comparisons between hemodialysis hd and peritoneal dialysis pd therapy for patients with esrd generally have focused on differences in morbidity and mortality between these treatment modalities. The necosad study performed by termorshuizen et al. Both processes involve the removal of waste and extra fluid from the body. A randomized, controlled trial in patients with acute kidney injury dp gabriel1, jt caramori1, lc martim1, p barretti1 and al balbi1 1department of internal medicine, university hospital, botucatu school of medicine, sa. Hemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis are both treatment methods of filtering wastes from the body because the kidneys are no longer able to do so. Difference between haemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis. Peritoneal dialysis pd and hemodialysis hd are dialysis options for endstage renal disease patients in whom preemptive kidney transplantation is not. The following article compares a few points related to peritoneal dialysis vs. Firstly, hemodialysis uses a dialyzer, a manmade membrane that removes excess fluids and waste products to filter the bloodstream. Survival analyses comparing hemodialysis and continuous ambulatory peritoneal dialysiscontinuous cyclic peritoneal dialysis capdccpd, a newer and less costly. Background and objectives incenter hemodialysis hd is often the default dialysis modality for older patients.
Daily home hemodialysis dhd is associated with fewer hospital admissions and a lower risk of modality failure than peritoneal dialysis pd, according to a new study. Hemodialysis is an extracorporeal procedure, or procedure outside the body, for filtering uremic substances from the blood of patients. Jager, survival comparisons between haemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis, nephrology dialysis transplantation, volume 27. However, these studies focused on comparing the overall cost of each treatment regimen rather than the cost of a single hospitalization. Discuss with your family and definitely, your nephrologist before deciding on. Studies comparing patient survival of hemodialysis hd and peritoneal dialysis pd have yielded conflicting results and no such study was from southeast asia. Comparison of peritoneal dialysis and hemodialysis as first renal.
Some people are switched from hemodialysis to a different form of dialysis that uses fluid in the abdomen called peritoneal dialysis. An alternative to hemodialysis is peritoneal dialysis which most patients carry out themselves either at home or at work. Peritoneal dialysis, on the other hand, requires a catheter, or. Pdf considerable geographic variation exists in the relative use of hemodialysis hd vs peritoneal dialysis pd. According to the latest usrds data, moderate to severe kidney disease stages iii. My attention was caught by the recent article in cjasn which compared the mortality of peritoneal dialysis pd and hemodialysis hd patients in the first 2 years of dialysis therapy.
Here a person, who has acute or chronic renal failure requires the excess harmful metabolites to be removed from the body, lest cause complications of. Quality of life and physical function in older patients on. One general difference between hemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis is that hemodialysis is for those who still have some kidney function left, and peritoneal dialysis is for those who actually have kidney failure and are waiting for a kidney. This machine is called a dialyzer or artificial kidney. Basically, in hemodialysis, blood leaves the body, gets filtered by a machine called a dialyzer, and then returns to the body. Today, patients can choose among several medical treatments to save their life and continue living productively. Making the decision for which form of dialysis to treat end stage renal disease esrd is no exception. In his column, joel glickman talks about study limitations when comparing mortality rates for hemodialysis vs peritoneal dialysis. In peritoneal dialysis, the inside lining of your own belly acts as a natural filter. Peritoneal dialysis versus hemodialysis advances in chronic. This will help you learn more about these two different methods of kidney dialysis, also known as a renal replacement therapy. Kidney failure can be treated by either hemodialysis or peritoneal dialysis. Home hemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis national kidney foundation has divided kidney disease in five different stages reflecting progressively higher severity of loss of kidney function.
Cost comparison of peritoneal dialysis versus hemodialysis. These reports of chronic kidney disease patients starting their dialysis treatments using peritoneal dialysis support the findings in other recent studies which appear to be consistent. Peritoneal dialysis kidney failure used to mean the end for those who are suffering from this medical condition. The selection of pd or hd will usually be based on patient motivation, desire, geographic distance from an hd unit, physician andor nurse bias, and patient education. Peritoneal dialysis peritoneal dialysis shares the same basic principles as hemodialysis to do the jobs that the kidneys no longer can albeit in a different manner. Make sure conditions like diabetes and high blood pressure are wellcontrolled. Unfortunately, many patients are not educated on pd before. Pdf hemodialysis versus peritoneal dialysis, which is. Better quality of life of peritoneal dialysis compared to. Results of these studies have been inconsistent, with.
Hemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis have different costs. Why is peritoneal dialysis underutilized in the us. Knowing the difference between kidney diets and the guidelines for peritoneal dialysis pd and those for incenter hemodialysis hd may be helpful in making your pros and cons list. Peritoneal dialysis vs hemodialysis the pros and cons of. Its machineless, so theres no need to visit a dialysis center or hospital 3. Although kidney transplantation is the preferred treatment method for patients with esrd, most patients are placed on dialysis either while awaiting transplantation or as their only therapy. The first type of peritoneal dialysis is called continuous ambulatory peritoneal dialysis capd. Considerable geographic variation exists in the relative use of hemodialysis hd vs peritoneal dialysis pd. The choices for a patient who reaches the point where renal function is insufficient to sustain life are 1 chronic dialysis treatments either hemodialysis or peritoneal dialysis. Access site your doctor will create a vascular access site in the arm before hemodialysis. Hemodialysis vs peritoneal dialysis difference between. Wastes are taken out by means of a cleansing fluid called dialysate, which is washed in and out of your belly in cycles. Treatment starting with peritoneal dialysis pd may lead to more favourable survival in the first 12 years compared to starting treatment with haemodialysis hd. Kidney disease treatment decision guide fresenius kidney.
Survival analyses comparing hemodialysis and continuous ambulatory peritoneal dialysiscontinuous cyclic. There are three types of dialysis, but mostly two types of dialysis i. There are two main types of dialysis to treat kidney failure. Instill a special solution called dialysate into the peritoneal cavity. Few centers use assisted peritoneal dialysis pd, which enables treatment at home. What is the difference between hemodialysis and peritoneal. While both these medical procedures have the same endgoal, they greatly differ in a number of ways. Surgically place a soft, hollow tube into the lower abdomen near the navel. Comparison of hemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis. Pdf comparison of hemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis survival. Our aim was to compare the survival of dutch hd and pd patients. This observational study compared quality of life qol and physical function between older patients on assisted pd and hd. Differences between hemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis. This study aimed to compare the survival outcomes of patients with endstage renal disease esrd who started dialysis with hd and pd in singapore.
This is the preferred treatment for almost 90% of all dialysis patients. Difference between hemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis. Diffusion, convection, and dialysis machines c hronic renal failure is the final common pathway of a number of kidney diseases. We developed cox regression models using 16643 patients from the dutch endstage renal disease registry renine adjusting for age. The detail descriptions about these treatments are as follows.
Homebased versus incenter dialysis evidencebased synthesis program. So whats the difference between hemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis. The standardized mortality ratio for capdccpd compared with hemodialysis was 0. Over the years there have been countless studies regarding survival in hemodialysis versus peritoneal dialysis patients and they have provided conflicting results. Do results differ depending on whether peritoneal dialysis was the initial. Hemodialysis hd and peritoneal dialysis pd are the two common forms of dialysis therapy for esrd. In hemodialysis, blood is pumped out of your body to an artificial kidney machine, and returned to your body by tubes that connect you to the machine.
Survival comparisons between haemodialysis and peritoneal. The peritoneal approach to filtering blood differs from hemodialysis because it does not use a machine external to the patients body in order to remove excess water and waste. Studies comparing survival between these modalities have yielded conflicting results. Another general difference between hemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis is that in hemodialysis, the filtration of wastes occurs in a machine, while in peritoneal dialysis, the filtration occurs within the abdomen. Fulltext pdf international variations in peritoneal dialysis utilization and implications for practice. Dialysis vs hemodialysis peritoneal dialysis vs hemodialysis one of the most appreciated inventions in the field of medicine is the dialysis machines and the principles involved in dialysis. Hemodialysis versus peritoneal dialysis nephroplus. The main differences between hemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis. The most common side effects of hemodialysis include low blood pressure, access site infection, muscle cramps, itchy skin, and blood clots. Peritoneal dialysis pd and hemodialysis hd are dialysis options for endstage renal disease patients in whom preemptive kidney transplantation is not possible. The dialysis population is projected to increase sharply due to the nations aging population and the high prevalence of diabetes. There are important risks and benefits that must be assessed when deciding between peritoneal dialysis vs hemodialysis. Diabetes has become the most common cause of endstage renal disease esrd requiring renal replacement therapy rrt in most.
Your health care provider can give you more information on this if you are a candidate. The question of which dialytic method provides the best patient survival remains unresolved. Most people have the freedom to choose the treatment option that best fits their lifestyle and health needsespecially if the decision is made before reaching esrd, also known as stage 5 chronic kidney disease ckd. Cost comparison of peritoneal dialysis versus hemodialysis in endstage renal disease article pdf available in the american journal of managed care 158. Comparative effectiveness of homebased kidney dialysis. Peritoneal dialysis vs hemodialysis and mortality medscape. High volume peritoneal dialysis vs daily hemodialysis. Hemodialysis hemodialysis also spell as haemodialysis. This study aimed to compare healthrelated quality of life hrqol over time in patients initiating hemodialysis hd or peritoneal dialysis pd. Comparison of patient survival between hemodialysis and. Pdf background studies comparing patient survival of hemodialysis hd and peritoneal dialysis pd have yielded conflicting results and no such study.
1377 806 1436 1218 368 47 1435 465 921 736 608 1539 202 1113 935 639 547 1417 852 691 525 641 712 772 537 140 1185 1108 1173 169 825 852 756 1137 881 1085 537 1183