Article pdf available january 2016 with 2,299 reads how we measure reads. Majority rule and minority rights annenberg classroom. Majority rule is limited in order to protect minority. The filibuster protects the rights of all senators and the. In a situation where majority rules, how can a nation ensure that all citizens have equal treatment and equal opportunities, even those who are not part of the majority. Majority rules with minority rights is an important principle in democracy according to which public policy is determined by a majority of citizens, but the majority may not rightfully use its power to deprive minority groups of their rights. Corporate litigation, majority rule, minority protection. Minority protection prevention of oppression and mismanagement under companies act, 1956 the rule of minority. In every genuine democracy today, majority rule is both endorsed and limited by the supreme law of the constitution, which protects the rights of individuals.
The foss case, firmly established the principle of majority rule and minority protection. Man is free to act in a manner that will preserve hisher life, culture, love ones and including their belongings. The worksheet and quiz help test your knowledge of majority rule vs. Minority rights, majority rule seeks to explain why majority parties have consistently been so powerful in the u. Thus, if, say, in congress, all redheads were despised, congress wouldnt be able to. Introduction it is trite that equity will not suffer a wrong to be without a remedy, but the majority rule in corporate governance seems to undermine the whole jurisdiction of equity especially where there is an increasing need for equitable control of the majority. Majority rule is limited in order to protect minority rights, because if it were unchecked it probably would be used to oppress persons holding unpopular views.
This article critically examines the commonly held proposition that madison advocated separation of powers as a means of thwarting majority rule, or, conversely, of protecting identifiable minority interests. Using the majority rule, majority shareholders may fix for. Simply put, it means that the majority will make decisions, but the minoritys rights are protected the majoritys beliefs cannot be used to abuse the minority. Mcgann argues that majority rule helps to protect minority rights, at least in settings. Minority rights are generally the same as anybody elses, but there are certain exceptions. This document is highly rated by b com students and has been viewed 2665 times. In a civil society, it is everyones responsibility to protect the rights of the minority, and this protection is often championed through political action by the nonprofit sector. Minority rights on oppression and mismanagement under. Teichmann, conflicts of interest between majorities and minorities in the eu member states private company law, spain, thomson reuters aranzadi, 2019, 117 169, deirdre ahern. Majority rule but minority protection majority rule.
Majority rule is a concept inherent in any democracy. Pdf the company act i960 merely incorporated the common law position with its shortcomings and that unfortunately form the foundation of. The principles of majority rule and equal treatment securities. Free essays on majority rule minority protection essay. Yet pure majority rule is also majority tyranny, and pure consensus slows government to a snails pace. Minoritarianism or minorityism is a neologism for a political structure or process in which a minority segment of a population has a certain degree of primacy in that entitys decision making. For the purpose of this project, the protection afforded to minority shareholders will be critically evaluated and its effectiveness will be highlighted to portray the usefulness of the available remedies. Majority rule is a way of organizing government where citizens freely make political decisions through voting for representatives. It is in the enlightened selfinterest of the majority to protect the rights of the minority because one day the.
One of the most interesting thing about incorporation of a company, is the legal personality clothing that incorporation clothes an organization with. The members pass resolutions on various subjects either by simple majority or by special majority. Chapter four majority rule and minority protection studocu. This paper demonstrates that majority rule offers more protection to the worstoff minority than any other system, in that it maximizes the ability to overturn an unfavorable outcome. This clause, which mandates unanimous approval for major activities by the llc, ensures that even minority interests are represented as a default rule. Minority rights may also apply simply to individual rights of. Majority rule, minority rights by angie murthy on prezi. Rahmani, ataollah 2007 majority rule and minority shareholder. Majority rule and minority rights 54 words 123 help me. Minority rights are the normal individual rights as applied to members of racial, ethnic, class, religious, linguistic or gender and sexual minorities. Senate protects the rights of senators to debate and amend legislation, thereby protecting the interest of the american people. Your browser doesnt seem to have a pdf viewer, please download the. As majority rule is used in matters of governance in both companies and strata title developments, there is a.
Being ironic one can easily say that only the problems are common in. The principle of rule by majority has been applicable to the management of the affairs of the companies. Pdf the principle of majority rule and minority protection. Otherwise, a minority holding economic, social, and political power would use its power to dominate the majority of the citizens, thus instituting the antithesis of democracy. House of representatives while minorities often prevail in the senate. The protection of minority rights is an act of selfinterest in a democracy, in which constant change. The principle of equal treatment balances out the principle of majority rule together with the more detailed minority protection provisions of the limited liability. With this a company becomes a legal entity of its own which is capable of suing and being. However, there are other values that we need to take into account besides political. Chapter four majority rule and minority protection. Minority protection, rights, and supermajoritarianism the only practical decision rule for legislatures that fully respects political equality is majority rule, as argued in the previous chapter. They involve numeric size, powerstatus, and counternormative position, but size is most.
The key shareholder remedies of derivative actions and oppression are comparatively discussed, with highlights of the similarities and differences in both remedies under canadian and. Majority rule and minority rights 54 words 6 pages majority rule can often lead to tyranny because of the pursuit of the majorities interests. Theoretical frameworks and national practice in the shadow of the eu. According to the principles of democracy, majority rule is a means for organizing government and deciding public issues. Hence both in practice usually amount to a shifting compromise between supermajority rule and minority rights. From company law and equity to strata title rachel leow1. Majority rule is a decision rule that selects alternatives which have a majority, that is, more than. Minoritarianism may be contrasted with majoritarianism, but with legislative power being held or controlled by a minority group rather than the majority. The designations employed and the presentation of the material in this publication do not imply. Majority rule is a way of organizing government and making public decisions. A reflective analysis of the nigerian corporate practice. The researcher shall also examine the statutory protection that the minority shareholders have under the indian companies act of 1956. Minority protection, rights, and supermajoritarianism.
Majority rule and minority rights the very foundation of democracy is held by two pillars, the principles of majority rule and protection of the rights of individual and minority. Rule by the people requires majority rule or consensus, for those are the best ways of discovering the peoples will. Besides, democracy means giving each one according to its due and this pertain to the rights of minority or an individual over the majority. The majority of these remedies are firmly rooted in the common law but recently, these rules have been codified under the companies act 2006. Majority rule and protection of minorities law trove.
The concept of the majority rule with respect to minority. Several definitions of majority and minority groups can be found in the social psychological literature. It is known may 1952, dahl 1956 that majority rule is the only decision rule that completely respects political equality. The international protection of minority rights a special report complied for the. How do majority rule and the protection of minority rights function in practice. Majority rule is applied in making decisions on public issues as well as for organizing the government. Unlimited majority rule in a democracy is potentially just as despotic as the unchecked rule of an autocrat or an elitist minority political party. Free essays on majority rule minority protection essay company law. It was a curious metamorphosis of the age long partnership rule to what constitute today the forefront principles of contemporary company law. Stated more formally, majority rule is the only binary decision rule that has the following properties. Majority rules and minority rights seems to be contradictory with each other, the dictum of majority rule and the protection of individual or the minority may not coincide with general rules. What is meant by majority rules with minority rights. Although we use this strategy in daily life as in the. Binder charts the history of minority rights in both chambers and explains how partisan battlesfought under rules inherited from the pasthave shaped.
Internal rules usually provided for majority rule, and the rule in foss v harbottle 1843 deliberately subjected minority shareholders to the rule of the majority shareholder. The researcher will then look into the rule regarding the minority rights and the exceptions to the majority rule. This chapter examines the various ways in which the law has tried and sometimes failed to protect minority shareholders. For the relations among shareholders, this is a major modification of majority rule. The principle of majority rule and minority protection. Democratic redistribution and rule of the majority pdf. Pdf majority rule and minority protection in private.
It does not mean that the majority has the right to practise oppression. Majority rule and minority protection in private corporations. Minority shareholder protection rules in germany, france. In some places, discrimination against minorities is so severe that jobs and places in educational institutions have to be set aside for them, or they woul.
This thesis examines, in comparative terms, canadian and nigerian laws relating to the concept of corporate majority rule and minority protection from majority opportunism and oppression in private corporations. Monday, january 19, 2014 definition of concept definition of concept minority does not get ignored and is able to get their complaints and concerns heard the minority always has the opportunity to become the majority all. In my view, the provisions were and remain a compendious way for parliament to say to the courts that the classes mentioned in the act are to be treated fairly in the sense of justly by. The concept of the majority rule with respect to minority rights.
888 739 191 175 1482 1134 1215 429 1253 1292 684 468 1278 899 1050 452 441 630 1530 1422 11 205 1022 550 1056 1172 286 1143 627 180 1476 1306